Islanders vote 'yes' for fish farm
Mowi plans high energy site after residents on Coll voted by 63 to 49 in favour of the development
A majority of residents on Coll have voted to support a Mowi Scotland proposal for a salmon farm in a high-energy area off the northeast coast of the island.
The positive vote follows an invitation from some islanders several months ago for Mowi to explore developing a site off Coll.
That led to Mowi giving a presentation about a potential farm to islanders in Arinagour in May. It also talked about its plans for newly acquired Sanda in Kintyre, and its operations off Muck, Rum, and Colonsay.
Equipment has developed
Mowi first looked at establishing a farm at a site east of Arinagour 15 years ago but decided the currents were too strong.
“At that time this would have been a challenging location, but development of pen and equipment technologies have progressed to the point where we are comfortable to operate in similar locations,” the company said in a presentation to the community.
“Since then, our farming knowledge in high current sites has changed significantly in parallel with innovation in equipment design suitable for operating in such locations.
“Using this new knowledge, we can explore and present for community discussion purposes a proposed fish farm design for one of these locations.”
14 jobs
The May meeting was attended by Mowi Scotland chief operating officer Ben Hadfield, who said a farm could employ 14 people. Mowi also outlined potential community benefits to include community housing, and onshore boating facilities, as well as an annual fund for the community. The company indicated that it would only pursue a fish farming operation on the Isle of Coll if the majority of the community supported it.
Following the May meeting, the Coll Fish Farm Advisory Group was formed, chaired by Coll resident Colin Kennedy, who has been a driving force in favour of a fish farm.
Kennedy is concerned about the future of the island, which he said has an ageing population, a lot of holiday homes, but very few employment opportunities and prospects for the future.
“The island is dying before our eyes,” said Kennedy, a former farmer and developer. He said he regularly travelled in the highlands and islands, adding: “The only places I see prosperity is where there is a fish farm.”
Due diligence
Kennedy said not all members of the Coll Fish Farm Advisory Group shared his views, and “we wanted to do due diligence for our island and properly understand fish farming and its impacts, positive and negative, for an island like Coll”.
“Thanks to Tiree Sea Tours, we were able to organise two trips for Coll residents to visit Colonsay where Mowi has a successful salmon farm and has really made a positive impact on the island. From investing in housing for the local community, to providing well paid jobs and a sustainable future for the island, I was impressed by everybody I spoke to and with everything I saw, including the clean environment around the salmon farm.”
In a public ballot this month, residents were asked: “Do you support the Mowi current proposal for the Isle of Coll?”
112 votes cast
“In total 112 votes were cast from the 163 ballot papers that were issued. 63 voted in favour and 49 voted against with a turnout of 68.7%. All ballot papers were issued to those registered on the electoral register,” said Kennedy in a statement.
“Following the ballot, Mowi Scotland will progress with a full proposal for a fish farming operation on Coll.”
The vote in favour of a fish farm comes despite a public meeting held on the island by anti-fish farming campaigner Don Staniford in the summer. Kennedy said that in response to a one-sided viewpoint presented by Staniford, the Advisory Group had asked aquaculture and environmental consultant Ewan Gillespie to give an unbiased presentation of salmon farming at a well attended public meeting.
Kennedy believes that it was Gillespie’s presentation of the benefits and downsides of salmon farming that swunSg the vote in favour of the farm.
200-metre pens
Mowi is understood to be looking at using 200-metre pens and expects a site to support a maximum allowed biomass of 3,000 tonnes or more.
Ben Hadfield, chief operating officer for Mowi Scotland, said: “This is a great result. Mowi has an excellent track record of working with island communities to provide well paid employment and create a sustainable future for people who wish to live and work on the island.
“Any applications brought forward by Mowi will undergo rigorous environmental assessment and extensive community engagement, and will be subject to the full planning and consenting process. We look forward to working closely with the whole Coll community on this project.”