Tribunal rules that UK class action against salmon firms can proceed
Waterside Class Limited is seeking compensation for consumers for alleged price fixing
A proposed class action in the UK that targets salmon farmers Mowi, SalMar, Lerøy, Scottish Sea Farms, and Grieg over price-fixing allegations has been given permission to proceed by a specialist competition court, reports legal news website MLex.
The action, by litigation vehicle Waterside Class Limited, is seeking up to £382 million in compensation for consumers who are said to have overpaid for salmon due to alleged price fixing by producers.
In April, the Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT) refused to grant a Collective Proceedings Order (CPO) in Waterside Class Limited v Mowi ASA & Others, although it left the door open for a revised application, reported financial law firm Macfarlanes at the time.
The CAT was not satisfied that the relevant costs and benefits justified continuing the proceedings, nor that it was just and reasonable for the applicant (Waterside) to act as the class representative.
Despite refusing to issue a CPO in April, the tribunal declined to strike out the claim. It observed that there was scope for a significantly reduced costs budget, particularly if Waterside co-ordinated with the Asda and Tesco proceedings rather than pursuing its claim independently.
Waterside was granted a CPO at a renewed certifcation hearing yesterday.
Formed for one purpose
Waterside Class Limited was formed specifically to pursue collective action against the salmon farmers, which were accused of operating a cartel between 2015 and 2019.
Waterside’s sole director and representative is Anne Heal, a former director of regulatory affairs at BT (British Telecom), reported to be a passionate advocate for consumers. Its action claims that the alleged cartel’s behaviour drove farmed Atlantic salmon prices up to 20% higher than they otherwise would have been over the course of the alleged conspiracy.
Macfarlanes reported in April that the tribunal acknowledged that collective proceedings were prima facie appropriate but declined to certify the claim at that stage on the basis that neither of the two relevant conditions for certification – eligibility and authorisation - were met.
Low estimated take-up
Regarding eligibility, the tribunal criticised Waterside for failing to provide an estimated level of class member (consumer) take-up, which it estimated at between just £7120,000 and £3.1m.
In contrast, Waterside’s proposed litigation costs budget stood at £15.75m (plus VAT), excluding an ATE insurance deposit premium of £5.26m to protect claimants from paying the opponent’s costs. Additionally – and as disclosed only following direct questioning at the hearing, which the Tribunal found troubling – a further 50% solicitor success fee, 30% counsel success fee, and up to £19.4m in contingent ATE premiums could be added to Waterside’s costs.
The tribunal found that it was “wrong, and potentially misleading, not to present these contingent sums, alongside other legal costs, on the application for certification”, wrote Macfarlanes.
Didn't explore cost savings
The tribunal also took issue with Waterside’s failure to explore cost savings by coordinating with separate proceedings the Asda and Tesco, which similarly seek to prove the existence of the alleged cartel and measure the size of any overcharge.
On Waterside’s salmonclaim.co.uk website, Heal is described as having “held a number of non-executive roles that demonstrate her advocacy for, and commitment to, consumers and citizens across a wide range of sectors”.
But in April, the CAT expressed concerns with Heal’s remuneration of £300 per hour in her role as director of Waterside, with projected total charges of up to £316,950.
“Class representatives self-authorising fees of this magnitude is undesirable and gives rise to a potential blurring of the lines between the interests of the class representative and the interests of the legal advisers and funders which they are required to scrutinise,” stated the tribunal.
Erso Capital
Waterside’s class action is being funded by litigation finance firm Erso Capital PCC Limited, a protected cell company registered in the Isle of Man. A protected cell company (PCC) is a single legal entity divided into a central “core” and separate, ring-fenced “cells”, where the assets and liabilities of each cell are legally segregated from one another and from the core. Firms like Erso Capital use PCCs to isolate individual legal cases or investment portfolios into separate cells so the financial risk of losing one lawsuit does not threaten other funded cases.